Comparison
Silent vs MyFitnessPal: Price, Privacy, Features
An honest comparison of Silent and MyFitnessPal: pricing model, free tier, ads, where your data lives, AI, platforms, and which one fits you.
These two apps make opposite bets. MyFitnessPal is a subscription service known for the largest crowd-sourced food database in the category. Silent is a one-time purchase that keeps everything on your phone. Here is where they differ, and who each one is for.
| Silent | MyFitnessPal | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $3.99 once | Premium is $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year. Premium+, which adds meal planning, is $24.99 a month or $99.99 a year. |
| Free tier | No. You buy it. | Yes, with ads and limits |
| Ads | None | On the free tier |
| Account required | No | Yes |
| Where your data lives | On your iPhone | On MyFitnessPal's servers |
| AI | On-device, Apple Intelligence | Cloud AI for meal scanning and meal planning in the paid tiers |
| Barcode or photo logging | No | Yes |
| Fasting timer | Yes, with Live Activity | Paid tier |
| Habit tracker | Yes | No |
| Platforms | iPhone | iOS, Android, Web |
MyFitnessPal details verified September 2026. Prices change; trust the store screen.
Where MyFitnessPal wins
MyFitnessPal is known for the largest crowd-sourced food database in the category. It scans barcodes and photos, which Silent does not. It runs on iOS and Android and Web, and Silent is iPhone only. If you share a food log with a partner on Android, or you would rather point a camera than type, MyFitnessPal is the more convenient tool and the subscription is the price of that convenience.
Where Silent wins
Cost and privacy. Silent is $3.99 once, which is less than a month of MyFitnessPal, and it never renews. There is no account, so there is nothing to leak. The AI coach runs on the phone with Apple Intelligence, so your meals and weight are never sent anywhere. It also does two things MyFitnessPal does not: a habit tracker with streaks, and a fasting timer that lives on the lock screen as a Live Activity.
Which should you pick?
Pick MyFitnessPal if you need Android or the web, or if barcode and photo logging are how you stay consistent. Pick Silent if you have an iPhone, you are fine typing what you ate, and you are done paying every year for a food log. Most people who switch say the second part was the whole reason.
Get Silent on the App Store, or read why people leave MyFitnessPal.
Quick answers
Is Silent cheaper than MyFitnessPal?
Yes. Silent is $3.99 once. Premium is $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year. Premium+, which adds meal planning, is $24.99 a month or $99.99 a year.
Does Silent have everything MyFitnessPal has?
No. Silent has no barcode or photo logging and is iPhone only. It adds a habit tracker, a fasting Live Activity and an on-device AI coach that MyFitnessPal does not have.
Which is more private, Silent or MyFitnessPal?
Silent. It has no account and no server, and its AI runs on the phone. MyFitnessPal stores your log on its servers and requires an account.